Very nice expression of a Pinot from south western Germany - from my high school home town. Starting to show its age with some bricking at the rim. Elegant nose with robust herbal and leathery undertones. Still fresh on the palate, well balanced acidity and subtle tannins. — 6 years ago
I've hit the last 4 out of 5 weekly wine committees and it has been a treat every time. This week, @Jeff Meyer hosted and schooled everyone on how good German wines can be!
I guessed Pinot Noir on all 4 reds...I got 3 correct, but missed this one. Very unique! Had some more world/RRV characteristics in the cedar/brushy undertones. — 9 years ago
A thoughtful rather powerful Pinot Noir Rosé (20% Trollinger, too), pale orange in color, redolent of grapefruit skin & yellow rose on the nose, with some heft, as I've got 2014 here in August '16, emerging in the weight. Not a frisky rosé, reflecting Schnaitmann's serious & head-turning Württemberg Pinot Noirs. — 10 years ago
More on the warmer side compared to the BFs from Austria before. Very primary, fruity nose with a lot of red fruits, campino bonbon and red currant sour drops. Nice acid, well balanced use of oak and a great length. Would love to see this guy again in 5 years. — 11 years ago
Tart ripe fruit — a year ago
Great crisp palette with lively acid and red fruits. Really appealing to start off a meal and a fun bottle to come with — 10 years ago
Undersung meunier, done by one of B-W’s greats. Slightly more rustic expression of pinot, age has rounded off the harder edges. Dark berry fruit, bit of forest-y stalk character to give it backbone. Not complex but resolved. Wonderful midweek drink. — 4 years ago
Awfully good. Structure and flavor profile very Morey but different minerality. Still young, easily another decade ahead. — 6 years ago
Evolving nicely. It still offera some of the blue/piney resin that I loved when it was young. Well balanced. — 7 years ago
Lacking a touch of acidity but otherwise a great blend! — 9 years ago
23/IX/2016
В аромате клубничный мусс, мята, мох, консервированные личи. Очень интересно, ненавязчиво. Тело лёгкое, сочное, ягодно-барбарисовое, с грибными нюансами, тонами мяты и тропических фруктов (маракуйя, дуриан); высокая кислотность. Субтильно. 17/20 — 10 years ago
Great White! — 11 years ago
Merlot vom Schnaitmann @ Fellbacher Herbst! — 11 years ago
Jay Kline

“Twist top, drop-top”; enjoyed over the course of a couple of hours. The 2020 pours a deep garnet/purple with a near opaque core; medium viscosity with moderate staining of the tears. On the nose, the wine is developing with notes of brambles, purple flowers, some pepper, funky earth and minerals. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium+ tannin and medium+ acid. Confirming the notes from the nose. The finish is medium+. This is a serious wine that puts the fun into funky. If I were to have been presented this double-blind, I would probably have called it Gamay. Drink now through 2030-ish. — 2 months ago