Rob Brobst III

9.3

Dark berries… A hint of chocolate… But wonderful balance not to mention the tannins are super fine… — 6 months ago

Chris Palmer

9.4

Eddy brought for Thanksgiving. We all enjoyed it — 3 years ago

Willem Booij

9.3

Tasting with Eddy Faller: more delicate nose, roses mixed with lychees. Sweet entry in the mouth (res sugar 30gr) it’s goes round and round, smoke comes in the back of the aftertaste. After the tasting my overall opinion is that the wines are pure, salty and silky. The fat around the backbone of all the wines make them quite approachable and less nervous then their opponents from Germany. It’s an other style and that’s good four the cellar 🤣🤔 — 5 years ago

Chris Palmer

9.6

Cory Martin brought this to Eddy and Kayla’s. We shared it on our first visit to our Granddaughter — 6 years ago

Seth Timen

9.6

Eddy. Abigail. Lisa — 8 years ago

Henry Lang

8.9

Great - had at the Eddy in NYC. — 9 years ago

Chris Palmer

8.9

From Jim Deitch York home (give to us by Judy).
Shared with Langdon, Max, Ruth, Eddy, Kayla.
Extremely dry, earthy and sophisticated (according to Langdon). I for one didn’t like it, esp the more I drank it. Max really liked it — 2 years ago

Chris Palmer

9.5

Eddy brought them on his birthday weekend. Very nice taste — 4 years ago

Willem Booij

8.9

Tasting with Eddy Faller: Round and fat, nice acidity and some sweetness. Fine balance — 5 years ago

Chris Palmer

9.7

Eddy gave me a 4 pack for my 60th birthday weekend. I REALLY like it! — 6 years ago

Seth Timen

9.3

Eddy Abigail Lisa — 8 years ago

Jake Baker

10

With the Caplan’s at the Eddy — 8 years ago

Rob Moose

9.6

Wow. Decanted off sediment 3 hours before serving and even the muddy remains tasted great. Dream tar and roses combo, with soy sauce overtones and silky tannins. This must have been impossibly rough in its youth. What a showing!! Eddy w/ C&C — 9 years ago

with Chris

Maya Gonzalez

10

Very smooth, not bitter, not too sweet - eddy doesn’t like the bitter aftertaste — 2 years ago

Noel Geisen

9.3

Collega Eddy nam heerlijke zijdezachte Brunello mee op bezoek. Meteen geproefd Top! — 3 years ago

Willem Booij

9.2

Tasting with Eddy Faller: nice smooth and silky wine, some smoke in the nose and granite stone sparks. — 5 years ago

Tom Wildenhaus

9.1

Wonderful very approachable wine. Easy like a Sunday morning. — 6 years ago

Tom Wildenhaus

8.9

Very very nice. Would interesting to see how it would age further. — 6 years ago

Caroline F

9.0

Bday dinner with Ben at The Eddy - nice Bordeaux blend — 8 years ago

Pat Taylor

9.5

Recommended by the sommelier at The Eddy in Manhattan. This was a true treat. Gorgeous pinky brown colour and expressive nose. Raspberry and strawberry all throughout and a surprisingly long finish of 30 seconds or more. Win. — 9 years ago