James K

9.7

The hype is real — 3 months ago

with Paul

Severn G

9.3

How does anyone not hoard (regular) Sazerac at ~$25?!
Incredibly smooth, great sweet note to the finish. Again, why haven't I not been buying this for years...?

(BTW Kirkland Bourbon at $30 is worth the price of admission, earthy oak note on the palate is quite similar to Buffalo Trace.)

Counter-Clockwise from top left:
Buffalo Trace (single-barrel selection), Jefferson's Reserve Very Old/Very Small Batch, Knob Creek (9yo), Kirkland Bourbon (7yo), St George single-malt (SM 015), Hillrock (Ancram NY, solera aged, Barrel No. 174), Berkshire Mountain Distillers Shay's Rebellion and Wild Turkey Master's Keep (Batch 0001, 17yo). — 5 years ago

Gregory Fulchiero

9.5

So subtle - dried orange peel, potpourri and creamed corn - a delight, thank Hugh — 7 years ago

Seth Shenkman

9.0

Super smooth — 9 years ago

Kyle Katterjohn

9.8

Thanks Cody Richardson for fun night. And LWR and a .45cal A1 — 9 years ago

Sean Diaz

9.5

Mmmmmm. That's the stuff. — 10 years ago

Dave

9.8

Well my night just got better. Still have half a bottle from last fall. Fingers crossed I'll get my hands on one this year. This is the most bourbony rye I think I've ever had. It's all there- cherry leather, caramel, cigar box, corn bread. It's so much like Pappy 15 but a little hint of rye 😊
Listening to Bill Monroe — 8 months ago

Carla

10

Barry and Emily engagement present. Ben likes a lot. Kayla and carla like — 5 years ago

Sadia Duquette

10

Very nice bourbon drink it neat or mixed. Makes great drinks — 7 years ago

Paul Peters

9.2

Balanced and smooth. — 8 years ago

Scott Samlan

10

Creamy smooth with incredible nice finish. One of the best I have ever had. For the price however I would take Michters 20 — 9 years ago

Anthony Capozzolo

9.8

One of my go to's! — 9 years ago

Daron Watson

9.2

Red Wheat #SingleMalt: malty Fo sho...smokey from char of the barrels — 10 years ago

Dave

9.8

Finally opened this because I bought a bottle from 2024. This is without a doubt the finest rye whiskey I've ever enjoyed. It's going to go way too fast. — a year ago

Norman

9.0

This is an very old purchase that I’m finally finishing off. It’s not high proof and so is an easy drinker and I think does well in an old fashioned — 3 years ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.2

Kentucky YPO Bourbon trip 11/16 — 6 years ago

Laura Purdy

9.2

Great vanilla and caramel flavors. Soooo smooth — 7 years ago

Gunja Gargeshwari

9.4

Best of the night - smooth with lots of character - better than Pappy 23 year old — 9 years ago

with Jason and Norman

Frank Kuo

9.4

Deep amber color shows her double oak nature. Nose of fragrant ester, green apple, oak, and hint of toffee. Very powerful nose. Taste is a dance of hot spice with creamy caramel, around this is some milky vanilla, apple, and chocolate note. Aftertaste is a pleasure with milk chocolate-like sweetness, a bit minty, dried figs, and powerful hot spice at the throats. This is a bold but well polished whiskey. — 9 years ago

Maxence Guilluy

9.3

Strong, peer, peche apricot — 10 years ago