George Hesse

9.1

Ken Wegner’s Hunt — 9 months ago

Stephen Redenbaugh

9.9

As close to perfection as can be..,, smooth, silken, 2-minute finish. Nose of ripe, preserved, wrinkled apples…complete, complex, hints of baking spices, lighter than anticipated, but packing that 80 proof wallop. I anticipate most of bottle will grace a cool winter evening in front of the fire for 2 couples! — 3 years ago

Matt Perlman

9.8

This may not be the mostly purely delicious wine I’ve ever had (though it is up there) but it’s undoubtedly the most impressive. Vibrant purple in the glass, shockingly primary for 60 year old wine. Stunning fruit and structure. Clearly this is immortal — 7 years ago

Conrad Green

9.6

Very light and pretty. Sour cherry fruit. Super clear with lifted high toned fruit. So gorgeous and floral and exciting. Wow! — 8 years ago

with BOT, Matt and 1 other

Ira Schwartz

9.2

A reticent nose but not dead . With some time it opened up with leather , forest floor, florals and balsamic scents. Another wine with more than adequate acid to allow a wine to go the distance.
Red fruit , earth and coffee all neatly preserved for 60 years. — 8 years ago

Ivan Nikolaev

9.7

1958, tasted on 7 February 2018. Still great structure, and rich aftertaste, with comes back several minutes after swallowing. Light mushrooms aroma, great with foi gras — 9 years ago

GaryWEdwards

9.5

A distinct nebbiolo from just above the Piedmonte Region. At 65 years, drinking beautiful with near zero cloudiness. Lush, long finish of raspberry — 3 years ago

Lars Fasel

10

Incredible. Tastes exactly like super old premium burg. Spectacular — 4 years ago

Ryo Hayashi

9.6

まだまだ熟成の余地あり！ — 7 years ago

Trace Harris

9.1

Really like as a spring / summer lightly wine! — 8 years ago

Conrad Green

9.7

Wonderfully intense fruit. Dark, gamey and with a sour cherry underbrush thing. Leaner but very pure and long. Tangy. Leather and a Smokey drive at the end. Excellent. — 8 years ago

with Howard, Walker and 2 others

GaryWEdwards

10

I can only say wow and thank you! — 9 years ago

Nniccolò Contenta

10

Absolute perfection 😇 — 9 years ago

Scott Kahn

9.1

Unbelievably great showing of a 65 yo Napa wine! Distinct from old Bordeaux - nice toasted oak notes persist fully integrated with dark fruit. A tue delight to have tasted! — 3 years ago

Conrad Green

9.8

This is staggering. What a bottle. Dark in color with delicate bricking round the edges this is pretty much a perfectly stored bottle. A gorgeous intense nose of plum, wild flowers. Balsamic, iodine, spice. So clear and pure. The palate has glycerin and gorgeous resolves but intense fruit. In every way this is stunning — 5 years ago

with Walker, Tony and 1 other

Knox Knox

9.0

Love this one!
— 7 years ago

Patrice Conxicoeur

9.0

A good illustration of how truly great Chateaux can not only make good wines in average vintages, but also wine that ages well. Respect. — 8 years ago

Marc Melser

9.4

We had this for our birthday bash and yes This is the year of mine and Cindy’s birth. A treat brought to us from my brother Ron. After several filterings, there was a sweet and sour nutty flavor. A real treat — 9 years ago

Jordi Pazo

8.9

Vila. 11° Premio de Cata por Parejas.
15.04.18 — 9 years ago

Jamie Prettitore

9.4

Wonderful start to@an amazing 40 year vertical of Barale Castellaro Barolo at Maialino — 9 years ago