If anyone wants a perfect example of a Cali merlot, give them this. Big blue fruit with some pine and cedar. It’s not subtle, but it’s good. If you’re a Merlot lover, get this. — 4 years ago
Easy drinking, nice and refreshing — 7 years ago
Strong oak sense, fruity and smooth — 8 years ago
From Acme wine club — 9 years ago
Straw yellow to clear robe. Light nose of melons green apples and grapes. Buttery melon taste with a light fizz and prominent tannins. Delightful medium finish carrying the taste of melons to the end. Lovely! — 9 years ago
My go to. Favorite. — 10 years ago
Complexity of dark fruit along with red currant berries and underneath side of tobacco leaf herb-leaf and cigar all together balances and deep on palate with yet soft structure at finishings 🤵🏼
Aromatic velvet and floral of rose garden 🕊 — 7 years ago
David Tate is the man. His Chardonnay is top notch - as close to Mersault as Cali can get. Where the fruit is always ripe, and sometimes over ripe, he is making chardonnay with finesse and elegance. Everything here is in moderation to create balance - gala apple, lemon, vanilla, ripe pineapple, honeydew, hazelnut - medium bodied, supple mouthfeel, no apparent sharpness in acidity, but plenty of it to support the touch of oak and malo. It's a chardonnay I could drink very often. 52 barrels produced, Sangiacomo Vineyards Carneros. — 9 years ago
So damn good! — 10 years ago
Ah-maze-ing — 10 years ago
Popped and poured; enjoyed over the course of two days and consistent throughout. The 2015 pours a deep garnet color with a near opaque core and some slight rim variation. Medium+ viscosity with moderate staining of the tears. On the nose, the wine is developing and beginning to show, some secondary characteristics with a combination of tart, ripe and desiccated, black and red fruits: brambles, cassis, green bell pepper, pipe tobacco, leather, cocoa, organic earth and baking spices. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium+ tannins and medium acid. Confirming the notes from the nose. The texture is that of a velvet glove. The finish is long and satisfying. Years ago, I cut my teeth on the wines of Ray and Nancy Coursen, especially their Elyse label while their Jacob Franklin label remained elusive to me. It’s clear there is similar DNA. This is a delicious, giving wine that is squarely in its drinking window. Drink now through 2030. — 2 years ago

Smooth, slightly sweet start. Green/spicy end notes, a bit stronger than I'd prefer, but good for smaller sips — 8 years ago
Slightly sharp start with a mellow finish. — 9 years ago
Nice stuff- originally was thinking "enjoyable wine" - just started opening up right as I finished dinner - revised my score 4 pts higher- suggest 1 hr decant before enjoying. — 10 years ago
Norman
Might have kept this a little too long as the flavors are a bit muddled. The aromas/nose on it fills the room so it’s very aromatic. The finish is long but all in the mid-palate and nothing in the cheeks so feels lacking. More acidic than I love. — 2 years ago