Odd Bins

Château Pontet-Canet

Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend 2015

Paul K
9.2

Actually kindof fell apart after 3 hours. Nose and palate were better 30 mins in. Chalking it up to odd bottle. — 6 months ago

Dave, Ray and 16 others liked this

Château Lafaurie-Peyraguey

Sauternes Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend 2001

(Split) — Intense apricot aromas and flavors, still very youthful, but also an odd medicinal/band-aid note that detracts a bit, on the other hand, this tastes like it’s 5-years-old, not sure what I think on this one?!?! — 4 years ago

Jim Powers
with Jim
Severn, Ira and 2 others liked this

La Conreria d'Scala Dei

Les Brugueres Priorat Grenache Blanc 2017

Definitely better on the second day, which is odd for a white. Pale in colour. Quite shy initially but opens up to reveal lots of spice and complexity, wrapped around the melon core of garnatxa blanca. Delicious though they are not giving it away at €18. — 7 years ago

Paloma

Napa Valley Merlot 2008

Shay A
9.3

This was my bottle, and it was opened alongside a ‘15 for comparison sake. Aromatics were similar to the ‘15 (red and black fruit) but less candied. More dirty, but not off putting. However, the finish on this was very unique...it turned very umami/earthy/herbal. Maybe an odd phase as it wakes up? Structure was still very solid (as expected for mountain fruit) so this may hold a while...

Almost two hours later: Better with air. Became more dark chocolate covered. Wow. The savory notes have faded and it’s showing a more rich and dark cocoa type finish. Very enjoyable.
— 7 years ago

Dan FitzgeraldMark FlesherClare Gillette
with Dan, Mark and 2 others
Mark, Paul and 27 others liked this
Mark Flesher

Mark Flesher

Very interesting wine. An initial pop and pour, this one had a very candied raspberry and cherry nose. On the entry, black cherry cola with some figs and a hint of dark cacao. The finish of this wine went to a very dark and soil rich truffle and mushroom for about the first 45 minutes. Almost seemed to have a straw or weedy kind of character. After an hour, the finish changed dramatically and this one was rocking. My goodness these Paloma Merlot are good.... If I could only keep my hands off of my younger vintages so that they could become older vintages!!
9.4

Vigneto Saetti

Rosso Viola Lambrusco 2016

This incredibly unique semi-carbonated Lambrusco is all about Red Delicious apples. Pretty crimson murky red with a tinge of copper on the brim. It’s completely dry with a bitter note reminiscent of apple skin. Tart cranberries and spiced cherry flavors formulate into a Dr. Pepper and nutmeg elixir. So unusual and so perfect for this time of year.

And more surprises - an odd cone shaped knobless Champagne cork that requires a corkscrew. It comes wrapped in a personal paper note from the winemaker about wine quality.
— 8 years ago

Daniel, Steve and 17 others liked this

Tyler

Santa Barbara County Pinot Noir 2009

Rick K
9.3

Found this in the odd lots bin at Kadota's Liquor near my old high school in Hilo, Hawaii a few days ago. Freaking delicious! Earthy, cherries, but very high toned for a SB Pinot of this era. Wish I still had some of this in my cellar. Justin was killing it from Day 1. — 8 years ago

Shay, Craig and 3 others liked this

Hartwell Vineyards

Estate Grown Cabernet Sauvignon 2014

Paul J
9.3

1hr+ decant. Dark red color with purple elements. Cherry, medicinal, and subtle graphite on the nose. Medium plus depth with ample Napa sweetness. Unfortunately a very short finish which is odd. I’d drink up very soon! — 4 years ago

Brooke Weaver Jakubowski
with Brooke
Tom, Shay and 6 others liked this

Cherry Pie Wines

Stanly Ranch Pinot Noir 2014

Rotting fruit. Sweet and savory. Enjoyable but really odd. Will try again. — 7 years ago

Cantina Sociale Cooperativa

Riserva Copertino Negroamaro

Snagged this one after the wine buyer at my local shop said it had an odd “barnyard funk.” And it does, in the best way. I was excited by the herbaceous nose, and very happy with the wet clay and wood taste. There’s a complexity with slight yeast notes, and a nice balance of medium tannins. I drank it on the third day after opening and loved the additional prune and dried fruit notes that I got. I imagine this would age well. — 8 years ago

Shelburne Vineyard

Whimsey Meadow Rosé 2017

Odd but lovely. I completely agree with the sangria comment.
— 8 years ago

Old Rip Van Winkle Distillery

Family Reserve Rye

Very light nose of caramel, vanilla and gasoline(?). It’s much stronger on the palette with caramel, charcoal, tobacco, acetone, chocolate. The finish has an odd acidic/metallic note that isn’t very pleasant and lingers forever. Not as spicy as other ryes I’ve had. It’s very complex and interesting, changing multiple times over my 20 min tasting. I really like it. — 4 years ago

Scheid Vineyards

Odd Lot Red Blend 2015

Got from Kroger. Yum — 5 years ago

Château Musar

Bekaa Valley Red Blend 2003

Less funk than a typical Musar after a 2 hour decant. The mouthfeel is gorgeous with extremely soft tannins and just enough acidity. Orange peel, cherry, gravel and baked apple. Odd and delicious. — 7 years ago

Château Musar

Bekaa Valley Obaideh Merwah 2005

Honeycomb, raisins, baked apples. Oxidative style. Dry wine. Odd wine but surprisingly delectable. Try pairing with sashimi/sushi. — 7 years ago

The Four Graces

Willamette Valley Pinot Gris 2016

that didn’t last long....empty glasses and full recycle bins.... — 8 years ago

Jess Paley
with Jess

Château Mouton Rothschild

Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend 1966

Cedar, leather, and dust, dust, dust! Odd finish... — 8 years ago

Matthew Cohen
with Matthew
Yi-Fen liked this