Pinotman /// Andreas

9.5

Quite turbid. And dark. Must have stirred this up. Cork almost all the way through. Dark Raspberries, hint cherry, crushed rocks, hint Mexican limes, earthy, tannins fully resolved, herbs, orange zest - at its peak/drink up this won’t improve further and does not need to - a stunning example of Pinot. — a day ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.5

Ok there must be bottle variation on this one!!!!! The other bottle was pretty bad at 8.8 and this one excellent and really exceptional for a 14. Was at a lagoon/dock party and popped it because i thought who cares it’s shit anyways / what a mistake! no one really had a clue of the price of these wines/these days and what the treat was - note the party wine glasses at a dock in Carlsbad/CA - no formal notes sorry. — 8 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.5

At 20 years top wines needs to be in a good place. Not a fan of 20+ aging - for reds. AND? Excellent cork. Some oxidation. Brown tinge. Plenty of tannins left - give it 10 min at least!!! Tobacco, plums, peaches? Rust. Touch orange juice. Hint oregano. Really coats your mouth. Incredibly mellowed out. Plenty of acid. COMPLEX. A little rustic - not elegant but bold and big. This is what Pommard should be classic. World class for Pommard. To keep this longer would be nuts - drink up! What a wine! — 12 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.6

Excellent really. A real find by Lyle F.! — 5 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.4

Reviewed this vintage 3 times. Last bottle. Still excellent. Keep or drink over the next 2-5 years. Tons of tannins, kirsch, crushed marble. Mostly red fruit , touch blueberry, hint bitter. A reference wine.
— 6 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.6

Yes it is a Rosé but i stand by my points/rating. Brought from Münchweier in my suitcase to the US. It was a gift. Very hard to find - the winery in Baden/Germany - really - forget - your maps! Right next to the woods of the black forest. Dark for a Rosé and age worthy. Excellent always but especially this vintage. Rhubarb, Strawberries, Quince, Peach (underripe), pomegranate, bitter orange. Tannins from the skins. Who knows were Florian found these old vine Pinot Grapes. Together with Mark Enfields Rosé the best in the world right now and I assume long sold out! — 11 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

8.8

Very zippy. Love this wine works awesome with Indonesian Food @ Dija Mara in Oceanside. Green Apple. Light. 16$ by the glass they make a nice profit on this!!!! I assume the bottle is wholesale 10$. — 13 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.0

From Total Wines and more. This place essentially sucks when it comes to wines especially if you look for Riesling. But i needed a decent Gin and bought some wine. Citrus driven, touch herbs, salty light and dry. VERY dependable! Good quaffable party wine. 9.0 because the excellent 23 vintage shows. — 5 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.1

T.J. wine but an excellent vintage and less than 20 bucks. Scott alerted me so I bought a case. Last bottle. 2020 was not that good - have not gone back and tried 21…… — 8 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

8.9

Palate changed on my end who knows? Screwcap. Stinky too much ‘Sulfur’? I don’t enjoy this wine any more. Comes across as rich and big. Some hazelnut honeydew. Lacks finesse. 12.5%. Hint bitter. Lemon curd. Just too rich lacks elegance. If you look for German Chards to best white Burghs for the money this particular bottle ain’t it. May be they picked too late.
— 11 days ago