Doug Powers

8.9

Clean, crisp sparkling wine from a vineyard near Chalone, nicely aged, longish finish, very good. — 9 days ago

with Jim

Marc Melser

9.0

We had the 2017 Vintage on 9/22-13/25. This is a nice CA PN. Scents and tastes of red cherry, raspberry and cinnamon. Silky mouthfeel. Would buy more — 3 months ago

Eric Urbani

9.1

Ed did a great job on this one — 4 years ago

John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

9.1

Really great. Aged perfectly. — a month ago

Kelly Perkins

9.4

God flavor. Mellow — 2 months ago

Steve Goore

9.1

This $10 bottle is a winner. Light maroon color with red berries and beautifully balanced tannins. Finish was nice too and even better with food. — 4 years ago

Erik Longabardi

9.5

Should’ve bought more. Featherweight while very complex — 5 years ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.2

I love his wines and I guess lucky for me was added to his e-mail list a decade ago. This wine has now typicity aka terroir which comes from this vineyard (the vines are getting older he started out when they were quite young). Pear/honey on the nose - tons of acid, meyer lemon, sour mandarine on the back palate very restrained fruit. Not tropical or floral at all. Sharp clean and crisp. Almost steely. Very burgundian in style - folks would have a very hard time to identify this as CA in a blind tasting. 2 Puncheons produced and just 12.9%! (His Watson Ranch {napa}is my #1 but allocated followed by Heron Lake {wild horse valley}. Those 23‘s I will review in the future. — 2 months ago

John Willison

9.1

Melon rind, white flower, a bit of funk. Always interesting. — 5 months ago

Frank B

9.0

Normally I don’t like tropical fruit notes, but this was very nice. The finish was long and everything was very balanced. — 4 years ago