Franken

Weltner

Hoheleite GG Sylvaner 2023

Timothy Eustis
9.4

Melon and savory. Brilliant. Keep it coming. 2023 — 3 months ago

Weingut Weltner

Rödelseer Schwanleite Alte Reben Trocken Sylvaner 2023

Lyle Fass
9.5

So good. Freakish in the right way. Nose of herbs, keuper, minerals and more. A bit closed but it’s also a bit cold. Palate is just killing it. Juicy and clean with awesome texture and density. Sapid and almost tannic on the finish. So much going on. Insane inner mouth aromas. Really elegant. Unreal length. Just a rock star. Will be back once nose opens up. Unreal complexity and finish. Gorgeous. Nose is wide open now after around 10 minutes. Stunning. Lanolin, herbs and lemon lime. Expansive and so much depth. So good. — 7 months ago

S.S., Scott@Mister and 7 others liked this

Weingut Richard Östreicher

Rossbach Chardonnay 2021

Nose: gorgeous field of white flowers. Lemon flowers. More dense as it opens. A hint of apricot skin. Just a hint to add complexity. Some sea breeze. Like a mist of it. A perfect perfume. Intense but not obtrusively so. Inviting but not insisting.

Palate: so elegant. White flowers. Sweet minerals. Memory of a sweet lemon.

Chablis but more elegant and ephemeral. Top end aromatics and elegance but less dense than a grand cru.

Singular.

As this opens you get more of that grand cru elegant rich roundness. Super bright.

In the running for the best german chardonnay. Certainly the best old school Burgundian style one.

Fass selections
— 2 years ago

Aravind, Bob and 1 other liked this

Rudolf Fürst

Pur Mineral Riesling 2021

Lyle Fass
9.3

Gorgeous nose of sweet greens, minerals, sweet melon, white flowers and some white cherries. Such a clear and classic nose from this corner of Franken. Palate is crunchy with huge acidity and delicious, palate slathering minerals. Juicy with wonderful purity and freshness. Terrific mouthfeel and awesome mineral, crunchy texture and that licking a rock feeling that elite German riesling has. Great grip and concentration and a delicate tannic structure. A triumph. — 3 years ago

Peter, Jean-Philip and 8 others liked this

Weingut Josef Walter

Centgrafenberg Frühburgunder "J" Trocken 2007

Nose has ripe black cherry, blackberry, spring violets, vanilla, melted bittersweet chocolate and dry earth.

Palate has dried black cherry, ripe black currant, ripe plum, wet tree bark, molasses bread and under-ripe cherry, slightly tart with medium tannins.

Bottled under Stelvin closure, opened for slow oxidation 6H, then decanted 2H, more time appreciated. Notes to be updated.

24H Update:
Nose exudes ripe, sappy dark red fruits, just overrunning the Gabriel Glas, light (warm) molasses, brown bread dough and black cherry syrup reduction. Palate is crazy, all prior traits but with a sweet reduction and the acidity actually picked up. Moving this score from 9.4 to 9.5, likely one of the finest red German wines I've ever tasted. An equal to finely aged Burgundy wine.
— 6 years ago

Aravind, Jason and 27 others liked this
Lyle Fass

Lyle Fass Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Walter needs age then he can compete against everybody. But the age is critical.
Severn G

Severn G Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Erik Longabardi The Frühburgunder, with age is very special, compete with Burgundy any day.

Weingut Josef Walter

Centgrafenberg Trocken Riesling 2019

Lyle Fass
9.5

Gorgeous nose. Complex. Perfect balance of minerals, confectionary aromas and fruit. Awesome depth and purity. Like a Riesling gumdrop. Superb minerals and an herbal aroma. Deep, subtle and elegant nose. Wow. What a palate. Deep, incisive, complex and so pure. Just insane purity. So clean. So balanced. This is really great. Wow, 19 is legit. Savory, sour, sweet and deep. It has it all and all is in harmony. Nose is just ethereal. Palate is dense and so elegant with aggressive minerality. So pure. So sappy and deep. Clean and balanced. Just super impressive .

9.4 to 9.5 with air. Wowsers. So deep. Breadth here is remarkable as is the length.
— 6 years ago

Arden, Aravind and 6 others liked this

Weltner

Hoheleite GG Riesling 2023

Lyle Fass
9.6

Outrageous nose of pulverized rock, quarry dust, clear rock candy, cotton candy, chlorophyll and sweet greens. Almost no conventional fruit, just a blizzard of minerality. The palate is unbelievably juicy, refined and pure, with immense concentration, density and a wall of flavor that somehow remains weightless. Stunning sapidity, endless mineral persistence and a long, echoing finish. Genius wine, and it is only going to get better. — 4 months ago

Zach, Ray and 10 others liked this

Horst Sauer

Escherndorf Am Lumpen GG Silvaner

vintage 2016 | paired with a trio of fish: salmon, cod and sole | beautiful ripened — 8 months ago

Paul, Brian and 14 others liked this

Weingut Weltner

Rödelseer Küchenmeister Trocken Sylvaner 2023

Lyle Fass
9.5

Fantastic. Brilliant palate. Superb integration and confident. So elegant. Mineral on an elemental level and such luscious mouthfeel with such a nice touch of lush opulence. Masterful. Aromas are a bit mute as it was in the back of the fridge. Lol. — 10 months ago

Zach, Jay and 10 others liked this

Weltner

Brut Sekt Riesling 2016

F ya. Really thrilling fruit. Kind of demolishes the fruit on any other sparkling riesling I’ve had. Apple, lime, citrus pith, kumquat, kiwi. All slathered thick with minerals. And nonetheless practically weightless. Very unique. — 3 years ago

Ted, Paul and 15 others liked this
Lyle Fass

Lyle Fass Influencer Badge Premium Badge

I am biased but I think this is best riesling sekt in germany. apologies to lauer and breuer.
Josh Morgenthau

Josh Morgenthau Influencer Badge

I share your bias. I love Lauer but this is viscerally thrilling in that special Weltner way…

Weltner

Hoheleite Großes Gewächs Erste Lage trocken Riesling 2020

Pure minerals. How does this smell perfumed of minerals? Like floral minerals, and a fresh sweet spring smell, like sugar snap pea. Palate is a mini acid bomb (explosive but not lethal) with tropical pineapple and limey citrus that’s achingly beautiful. Just a mind boggling bottle and stunning value. — 4 years ago

Eric, Tom and 23 others liked this
Severn G

Severn G Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Yeah, one of the best bottles in the Weltner line up.

Weingut Josef Walter

Hundsrück Trocken Spätburgunder ,,J" 2015

I have to say, I’m gobsmacked, fallen in to this and can’t get up. So much going on here! Black cherry/ cran/ raspberry, tobacco, (mint? Wtf). Opens tight as a dovetail joint; decant and ignore 2 hours plus. Then: so mouthwatering, pure, light, agile, warm and gloriously complex, glittering like a prism. I shall not squander my bottles. — 6 years ago

Lyle FassMatthew Cohen
with Lyle and Matthew
Lyle, Matthew and 14 others liked this
Lyle Fass

Lyle Fass Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Yup. This is an all time spatburgunder
9.5

Weingut Josef Walter

Centgrafenberg Franken Trocken Pinot Noir 2015

Lyle Fass
9.5

Drinking right at its apex. Beautiful mature nose: sweet Pinot fruit, sous-bois, a little mushroom, old oak fully absorbed, and very expressive minerals. But the palate is the story. Velvety, sweet-fruited, seamless and polished, with gorgeous tannin quality and all the oak now integrated into the wine instead of sitting on top of it. Mature, elegant, luxurious, but still alive and precise. A rare 11-year-old Franconian Pinot caught perfectly. — 4 months ago

Scott@Mister, Zach and 6 others liked this
Erik Longabardi

Erik Longabardi

The master

Weltner

Rödelseer Küchenmeister trocken Riesling 2013

Lyle Fass
9.5

Confectionery aromas but also a richness. Gorgeous, complex aromas. Spice, cotton candy, umami. Palate is rich, ripe but also has that bee sting quality. Unreal purity and balance. Super clean. What an opulent mid palate. Stunningly delicious. — 8 months ago

Ira, Ray and 8 others liked this

Rudolf Fürst

Bürgstadter Spätburgunder 2022

Lyle Fass
9.3

Nose is more florals. Complex cherries and so aromatic. Juicy and clean and a step up in complexity and freshness. So pure and elegant. Lovely. Lovely finesse. — 2 years ago

Severn, Pinotman and 2 others liked this

Rudolf Fürst

Centgrafenberg GG Riesling 2021

Lyle Fass
9.6

Nose is chlorophyll, mineral and sweet green. So evocative. Sea air. So layered. Some smoke. So elegant. White flowers. So pretty. Palate is so crystalline. Unreal purity. Elegant and finesse driven. Faint peach fruit and incredible acidity and depth. It glides on the palate. Really juicy. Long. Just another wonderful 21. — 3 years ago

Ron, Pinotman and 7 others liked this

Weingut Weltner

Rödelseer trocken Chardonnay 2021

Lovely Chardonnay from Germany. Mineral and floral on the nose. Apple, pear and lemon on the palate. Juicy acidity. This is a big wine, but fresh and bright, totally unlike a big buttery Chardonnay. — 4 years ago

Raul, Tom and 6 others liked this

Weingut Josef Walter

Centgrafenberg Trocken Spätburgunder J 2007

Nose has burning vines, charred black cherry, wet garden soil, decaying leaves and cooled bacon.

Palate has sweet & tart cherries, dried black currant, spicy tannins with granite-like minerality.

Bottled under Stelvin closure, opened for slow oxidation 6H, then decanted 2H, more time appreciated.
— 6 years ago

Aravind, Jason and 24 others liked this

Weingut Josef Walter

Centgrafenberg Trocken Silvaner 2019

Lyle Fass
9.0

Very exiting nose. Confectionery sugars, greens that are sweet, fiddlehead ferns, sugar snap peas, mineral and airy. Even a hint of saline. Palate is elegant, linear and focused. Juicy and clean. A bit simple. Nice but the J bottling of this is really a big step up. Nice length. Good. — 6 years ago

Severn, Dick and 5 others liked this