Sam Shaffer

9.5

I mean this wine is so money. Smooth, fruity, Italian rusticity in the best way. Unbelievable — 3 months ago

Matt Perlman

8.9

Fruit still holding on, mushroom, balsamic, prune, wet earth. Tertiary definitely starting to take over — 4 years ago

Nniccolò Contenta

9.6

First out of 3 Rinaldi Barolo that hasnt been fucked! When they Are good they Re soooooo goooood. Layers of beauty and hauntingly aromatic. Seductive expressive And still a big boy but goes down smoth — 9 years ago

Peter Heidt

10

...have to disagree with the wine pros in this one. This was fruity yumminess... Looks like a Brunello, smells a fruit orchard... 5-years in oak; you wouldn't know it. Scotty S. holding court at Villagio... — 10 years ago

Mike Holzer

9.9

One of last bottles I bought in 2004 in Italy at winery. Absolutely gorgeous nose. Cherry, floral, Coca Cola. Still has lots of fruit smooth tannins and great length. Drinking window by professional stated through 2015. Has at least 5 years in my mind. — 11 years ago

with Sean-Patrick

Stevie Burnich

9.6

Trac, I can't believe this took me so long to drink this. Thank you. — 12 years ago

with Trac, Caitlin and 2 others

Jamie Lauder

9.2

2016 vintage.
80% Sangiovese, 13 % Merlot and 7% Malvasia Nera.
Dark, shiny red ruby in colour.
Red/black berries, cinnamon and pomegranate on the nose.
Bright acidity and the tannins are softening.
Dark cherries, leather, black flowers, walnuts and a light, herbal earthiness.
— 3 years ago

Austin Bishop

8.9

Had this at mercato di San Lorenzo in Florence. Drank with some remarkable crostini. Pink peppercorns anchovies, stretchy cheese. Great glass , I like this . Minerals. — 7 years ago

Matt

9.0

Meaty, savory, ripe cherry, violet. Great sense of earth and pure Sangiovese fruit. Fresh with just enough tannic grip. Deep herbal notes bringing part of my brain back to S. Rhône. Pleasantly herbaceous. — 9 years ago

Emily Voland

9.6

This winery goes back to the 1500's. All mountain fruit , handpicked by women , (they have a better touch and feel) ... This is wine spectators #1 Chianti in 2015, #46 rated overall. Pretty Dicen. Where is the cheeeese — 10 years ago

Brash Higgins

9.7

1961 Gattinara at Maialino NYC. Killer booze, loads of energy — 11 years ago

David Musser

Sommelier The Little Nell

9.0

Hot vintage. 03's are on point right now. — 11 years ago

Ivan Peci

8.9

Fira medieval castello — 12 years ago

with Carlos

Eric Urbani

9.0

Presented as an ‘orange’ wine it has some oxidative character but not too much… hint of petroleum and really well balanced. Blend of trebbiano, chard, traminer, Malvasia, and SB. Biodynamic. I like! — 3 years ago

Anthony De Blasi

9.2

Raised in ‘cocciopesto’ which is an amphora kind of barrel based on clay and lime. Very fruit forward, soft tannins. Way better than I expected. Good job!
— 6 years ago

Ron Siegel

9.3

Another iconic producer in his 80's making a wine that is very unique. I was able to purchase a few of his older vintages recently but have not yet opened. You get a smorgasbord of flavors with dark fruits a touch of VA, balsamic & lots of spice. The restaurant gives him a whole lamb cooked and separated into single vacuum sealed packs for the opportunity to get 24 btls. — 9 years ago

Jörgen Lindström Carlvik

Owner, Brix Wine Consultants

9.3

Their 2006's has been sort of compressed but this beauty was pretty and expressive. Wonderful underlying structure will ensure a long life, but it's perfectly dried cassis fruit flavors are starting to take centre stage, as tannins have loosened up a little. There's still upside potential here. — 10 years ago

Rafael Landestoy

9.1

I enjoyed this one more than the previous Italian. Good fruit went well with the pork dish my wife prepared and I would definitely like to try again in s few years. Good stuff. — 11 years ago

with Ilida, Jorge and 1 other

David Singer

Sommelier/Wine Educator LibationEducation

9.0

Solid Nebbiolo with a little age, still very young. Improved significantly decanted after an hour. Starting to get the aged tar and violet notes. — 12 years ago

Joan Alberni

9.4

Portat per Anna del Friuli. Aromàtic i dens, amb gust i persistent. Molt bó. — 12 years ago