First night seemed more advanced than it should, with brownish rim, but perhaps that was sediment? Somehow seemed fresher the second day. — 9 months ago
This 2005 has settled nicely into a certain genteel personality, toned down it’s earthiness, and certainly a great companion to the pan-seared salmon with shaved truffles that my daughter and I had for dinner. Pleasant and adequate. — 5 years ago
Thus is why people chase Burdundy, absolutely perfect! — 6 years ago
These wines take a while to open up but once it happens there is some type of magic. The nose is stunning with a mix of red fruits that are fresh and ripe, herbaceous notes, and earthy tones, black tea and minuscule hints of leather. The plate is sheer elegance, the fruits show tart the flowers and herbs sing fresh and the texture is classic burgundy. — 7 years ago
In the mood for a good red Burg. In a good window. Forest floor, spice ant tart red fruit. — 3 months ago
Ruby but a bit brick. Leather, raspberry like fruits. Lots of spices. Clove. Red tea. Earthy. Complexity. Fruitiness M+ Sweetness M Acidity M Tannin M Bitterness M Body M Finish M % Elegant Balanced
Domaine Jean Tardy et Fils Aux Argillas Nuits Saint Georges 1er Cru 16 @6000, Fred, 260619 — 5 months ago
Black fruit, black cherries, spices, slight hints of licorice on the very Pinot Noir nose. The palate is structured, medium to strong bodied and very typical of Nuits Saints Georges but with good fruit and balance, making it a good delicious bottle, would be perfect with a touch more length. 90-91 pts
Un nez de fruits noirs, cerises noires entre autres, épicé avec une petite touche de réglisse. Une bouche structurée, assez large et Typée de NSG sans être trop puissante, un bel équilibre quand même et délicieux, même si on aimerait une finale un peu plus longue.90-91 — 6 years ago
Hard not to recommend this one. Entry level burgundy that is performing way above it’s status . Excellent wine. — 7 years ago
One of the better 2011s I’ve had in a long while. — 2 years ago
New Year’s 2021 — 6 years ago
Herb. A bit sweet, sour fruity. Strawberry, cherry, slightly licorice. Mid +. 2017 @2100, Kping, 201112 — 6 years ago
2nd bottle with similar notes — 7 years ago
Jay Kline

Georges Lignier’s holdings in this jewel of a 1er Cru account for nearly half of the entire vineyard.
Popped and poured; enjoyed over the course of several hours. The 2021 “Clos des Ormes” pours a ruby color with a transparent core; medium viscosity with no staining of the tears. On the nose, the wine is developing with beautiful notes of fresh forest berries: strawberry, raspberry, freshly cut red flowers, some finely ground black pepper, dried green herbs and a kiss of fine, warm spices. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium tannin and medium+ acid. Confirming the notes from the nose. The finish is medium+. What a lovely, rustic expression of Burgundy! This is the most soulful Georges Lignier I’ve had so far. The 2021 vintage may have played a part (I’m a fan of these cooler, harder vintages). Whatever, this is awesome and killer with rabbit sausage and lentils. Drink now (and take your time with it) or enjoy through 2046. — 3 months ago