Beautiful wine! On first sip I thought it might be a bit past its prime (it’d been Coravin-ed), but with my spaghetti it’s absolutely incredible (surprisingly). Notes of milk chocolate, subtle raspberry & blackberry, and a smooth ash & tar finish. Gets dustier and drier on its own. — 3 months ago
Medium bodied. Initially a bit of strong alcohol, but it eventually evens out. A small bit of sweetness and fruit begins to peek through. Not highly complex, but good drinkability, with nice weight to it. — 7 years ago
At its peak and so delicious. Excellent balance, very concentrated and flavourful, with a long and scrumptious aftertaste. Yummy! — a month ago
Dense Ruby with a Crimson rim. Aromas of red and black berries, chocolate, and smoked meat. Full bodied and muscular. From a single vineyard in McLaren Vale which was planted 124 years ago. Silky tannins. A great red on a cold night in Winter. Love the old fashioned label which probably hasn’t changed in 100 years showing the two Kay Brothers. Hope to have the patience to drink the last bottle in say 2028 to 2030. — 5 months ago

With Jay and Ted — 9 months ago
So good, smooth, not too sweet and not too dry. — a month ago
Celebrating our 21st wedding anniversary on the night of a lunar eclipse, this bottle seemed perfectly appropriate.
Poured into a decanter about 90 minutes prior to service and enjoyed over the course of a few hours. The 2005 Eclipse pours a deep ruby color with a near opaque core and some rim variation. On the nose, the wine is vinous with notes of black cherry, licorice, leather, dried red flowers, inorganic earth and spices. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium tannin (integrated) and medium acid. Confirming the notes from the nose. The finish is long. A rather deft pairing with grilled spiny lobster tail and T-bone steaks.
While this is not my preferred style (16% ABV !!!) there was something about it that kept my total interest. Yes, it was a big boy but it wasn’t some ponderous oaf. It danced across the palate with discipline and sophistication. Drink now, with an hour in the decanter to allow it time to freshen up, and through 2030. — 3 months ago
2012 vintage, still drinking very well. Turkish delight, chocolate and spice. Still has a firm grip which is impressive after 10 years. Cracking wine — 4 years ago
Tasty, light tannin, mod body — 6 years ago
Loved this wine — 8 years ago
Light but not cloying, funky, red fruit. Very good representation of natural — 8 years ago
Peter van den Besselaar
vintage 2019 | Still too young, quite a blockbuster but also very lush, smoked meat in smell, brushwood, good balance, Dead Arm seldom dissapoints — a month ago