Upside Wines

Scarpa (Antica Casa Vinicola Scarpa)

Tettimorra Barolo Nebbiolo 2021

Lyle Fass
9.7

Magnificent, deeply traditional Barolo. The nose opens with burning embers, campfire, road tar, dried roses and a huge range of savory exotic spice, then grows more loamy with air, bringing in wood shavings, old library books and classic Nebbiolo earthiness. The palate is dazzlingly concentrated but beautifully controlled, with exquisite red fruit, layers of cherry, superb linearity and wonderfully articulated tannins. Dense without heaviness, elegant despite the power, and architecturally complete. The finish is extraordinarily long and saturated with fruit, tannin and mineral detail. Already a superb Barolo, with obvious 9.7 upside as it continues to open.

After an hour and a half, this has gone to another level. The nose is now wildly floral and almost four-dimensional, with extraordinary depth and perfume, easily 9.7 to 9.8 aromatically. The palate has become even more beautiful, juicy and seamless, with velvety, sweet tannins and incredible tiny-berry fruit intensity. The structure is still serious, but everything is now more integrated and complete. 9.6 to 9.7.
— a month ago

Ray, Zach and 6 others liked this
Jay Kline

Jay Kline Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Lyle Fass this is what I was referring to!

Pertimali (Angelo Sassetti)

Riserva Brunello di Montalcino Sangiovese 2015

Jan A
9.3

A solid 93+ with upside potential with further aging. Particular fine nose. Hope that the palate will follow the nose in the coming years. — 2 years ago

Roman, Tom and 12 others liked this

Château Miraval

Côtes de Provence Rosé Blend

Paired with lobster coconut curry and upside down banana cake with rum raisin ice cream — 4 years ago

Beth
with Beth
Milissa and Daniel P. liked this

Château de Beaucastel

Vieilles Vignes Châteauneuf-du-Pape Roussanne 2000

In a great spot. Appears to have really shed some baby fat, the sucrosity of the fruit diminshing and the mineral and tertiary notes coming to the front. Lavishly textured, great length, a wonderful accompaniment to an array of vegetable dishes. Pineapple upside cake, roasted nuts, cooked yellow plum, marmalade, garrigue, cruahed stones, yellow blossoms, marzipan and honey, cream, olive oil. — 4 years ago

Shay liked this

Peay Vineyards

Estate Scallop Shelf Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 2017

92+ with upside potential. Saline blue fruits with some earth, and an expansive finish. Balanced structure and good acidity point to a wine with good aging potential. Bravo Peay. — 6 years ago

Michelle and Shay liked this

Clos Fantine

Cuvee Courtiol Faugères Mourvedre 2017

Bought from June and drank with the upside down dellaroccos pizza — 6 years ago

Jean-Paul & Benoît Droin

Vaillons Chablis 1er Cru Chardonnay 2018

Excellent wine. Many years of upside ahead of it. Some subtle oak, with tons of classic minerally Chablis character — 6 years ago

R. López de Heredia

Viña Tondonia Gran Reserva Rioja Tempranillo Blend 2010

Upside surprise. - at Chris & Mary’s — 2 months ago

Scott@Mister, Peter and 6 others liked this

Enderle & Moll

Muschelkalk Pinot Noir 2009

4 bottles within a week. Corks are in trouble they all seeped. Their top bottling in 2009 one barrel made / 60 year old vines / clone no idea? Still quite tannic. Needs 1 hour to open up before that flat/dull. Raspberries, tart cherry, red currant, chalky. Less complicated compared to 5 years ago some bottle variation. My strong advice - drink now (I re-corked 2 for 2029 for science). But honestly this is beyond its prime! OK gains significant elegance and pose after 2 hours of air. So yes still good but tough to figure out - and recommendation still the same drink up! May be folks luck out on the upside. — 8 months ago

Peter, Ira and 10 others liked this
Pinotman /// Andreas

Pinotman /// Andreas

Will add a note tomorrow after the bottle was on Argon over night.
Pinotman /// Andreas

Pinotman /// Andreas

Just tried again. Elegant will add 2 more points - but that does not change the corks!
Peter Sultan

Peter Sultan Influencer Badge

Hopefully we re all around for when you try your recorked bottles!! @Pinotman /// Andreas

Joseph Phelps Vineyards

Insignia Estate Grown Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon Blend 2019

Huge red fruit, soft tannins. An absolute baby with at least 20 years to evolve. Long lingering aftertaste on the mid pallet. Minerality and tannins will continue to become a bigger part of the taste profile. I won't try again for a few years. Huge upside. You can and should purchase while still available. A great addition to the wine cellar. Now that Phelps has sold it will be interesting to see what they do with Insignia.🍷🍷🍷🍷 — 3 years ago

Jack Riggs
with Jack
Paul, Shay and 8 others liked this

Château Doisy-Védrines

Sauternes Sémillon Sauvignon Blanc Blend 2014

Shay A
9.3

This was a bottle that was Coravined about 6+ months ago with about 3/4 remaining. Although young, I’ve always been a bit conservative when it comes to Coravined bottles and their freshness. Great sweet wine to pair with Thanksgiving food.

My first experience with Doisy-Vedrines, having only had Doisy-Daene previously. Would love to do a side by side. Tropically exotic and rich. Botrytis to the core. Pineapple upside down cake on the nose with honeyed apricots and orange marmalade. Viscous and totally giving on the palate with yellow fruit and and sweet spices. There’s not that honey roasted cashew profile I get with my favorite Sauternes, but this is a delicious and easy going wine that sports a great QPR. Room for improvement. (Also, this is evidently Barsac but labeled as Sauternes).
— 5 years ago

Milissa, Peter and 29 others liked this
Sharon B

Sharon B Influencer Badge

Sounds delicious!
Jody Scharf

Jody Scharf Premium Badge

Strong 💪 like bull 🐂

Seavey Vineyard

Caravina Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2012

2012 in Feb 2021. Big wine with some distinctive tastes. Great fruit with prominent minerals and graphite or iron. Comes off just a bit angular. Still lots of backbone and was still holding well the second day. Has a few years of life yet. Decant at least an hour. Has upside if things integrate a bit more. — 6 years ago

Henriot

Millésime Brut Champagne Blend 2008

A very complete nose of brioche, citrus and apple pie. In the mouth air is needed to really give this a chance to strut its stuff. Prominent but not overwhelming acid at first but an hour of air makes this as round as a beach ball. The palate starts to duplicate the nose with an hour or so of time. Another positive ‘08 champagne ,with upside from here. — 6 years ago

Shay, Jason and 56 others liked this

Clos Martinet

Priorat Grenache Blend 2020

From the insane clearance sales of the @plcb, comes this wine for $25. Often you have to tell them what they have in stock, or say…” could you please check in the back?”. Then out comes a sealed wooden, 6 btl case. ( in one instance.). If you’re lucky to hear of the clearance sales, and there’s some things you care for near you it can be great. One just 🤞then prays that the provenance was good.
The 2020 vintage in Priorat was a challenge from what I understand. Wet, with fungus and rot, etc.
The ordinarily Garnacha heavy blend was swapped for 55% Syrah, 34% Garnacha, some Cab. and others. A quite unusual winemaking regiment ensues with large tronchons, cement, and glass demijohns included.
So…this upside down year produced a very lithe, liquorice and mineral wine. Dusky dark fruit on the nose more reminiscent of St. Emillion. Grippy tannins but in harmony. Easy going for Priorat. If you’re lucky to have them, drink or hold ‘em. I feel lucky to have played my part and relieved the @plcb of their burden.
With Randy
— 5 months ago

Jay, Tom and 12 others liked this

Domaine Dujac

Morey Saint Denis Pinot Noir 2015

Sweet fruit. Intense dark plum. Still quite tight. Great fruit… stop young. A lot of upside — 2 years ago

David McNallyBex GreenMatt Lichtenberg
with David, Bex and 1 other
Douglas, Shay and 8 others liked this

Paul Lato

"Seabiscuit" Zotovich Vineyard Pinot Noir 2019

Shay A
9.3

I’m between 92-93 here, but this definitely has upside. Followed over three days.

Very translucent ruby in the glass. Extremely floral on the nose alongside plenty of juicy red fruit (strawberries, raspberries) and savory herbal spices. If whole clusters were used, it was minimal, but this isn’t a brash new world Pinot with overpowering oak. It trends toward a faint kirsch and black tea finish. I always enjoy Lato’s SRH Pinots and this is a good one now and will be for a solid 5-7yrs.
— 3 years ago

Milissa, Ira and 25 others liked this
Scott@Mister A’s-San Diego

Scott@Mister A’s-San Diego Premium Badge

He goes über-light. Not the easiest pinot to push/sell people on unless they are total cork dorks.

Domaine François Buffet

Champans Volnay 1er Cru Pinot Noir 2019

Ripe red cherry and spice, med + body, some toasty new oak, long. Lots of upside 👍 — 4 years ago

Aravind, Andrew and 11 others liked this

Rene Rostaing

Ampodium Côte-Rôtie Syrah 2018

(From a .375, decanted in the glass for 30 mins) A very expressive bouquet of dark fruit and violets. The palate told you this was an infant. Lots of intense silky fruit, medium acid and prominent tannins. Cassis, a slight hint of olives, and pepper but no signs of bacon fat. All the parts are there but they need to fraternize. Good upside. — 5 years ago

Andrew, Jake and 43 others liked this
Jan de Weerd

Jan de Weerd

Nice! Hope you have some put away to enjoy in 5 and 10 years for a full concert.

Upside Down

Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc 2019

Lovely wine. Easy to drink and pairs with most foods. Love it! — 6 years ago

Château Saint-Pierre

St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend 2014

Very serious. Big, beef-blood character. Way more extracted style than I recall from the ‘99. Will be interesting to revisit in a decade. Big upside development potential. — 6 years ago